Z'avez pas vu ma part de marché ? (le thread des précommandes US de comics)

[Gassian]

On en parle régulièrement, mais jamais au même endroit. Il me semblait donc qu'un thread rassemblant, mois après mois, les chiffres de ventes de comics avait sa place.
On verra bien.

[Fred le mallrat]

Le Top 50 d'AOUT
https://icv2.com/articles/markets/vi...cs-august-2024

Les mutants reprennent leurs droits en tête des charts (mais bon on est qu aux 1 voire au 2). Ultilmate et Batman tiennent bon. J ai l impression que Spidey décroche.
Alien Vs Avengers 14eme? ca me parait etre un echec...
Wonder Woman tient bien (bon c est un tie in Absolute power mais )

Si on étend aux ventes globales
https://www.comicbookrevolution.com/...ales-rankings/

	Citation:
	Debut Issues 1 Uncanny X-Men #1 (Marvel Comics) 5 Venom War #1 (Venom War) (Marvel Comics) 9 Spider-Man: Black Suit & Blood #1 (Marvel Comics) 10 Wolverine: Revenge #1 (Marvel Comics) 11 X-Factor #1 (Marvel Comics) 13 Wolverine: Revenge – Red Band #1 (Marvel Comics) 14 Aliens Vs. Avengers #1 (Marvel Comics) 17 Werewolf by Night Red Band #1 (Marvel Comics) 19 Gotham City Sirens #1 (Of 4) (DC Comics) 20 Spider-Society #1 (Marvel Comics) 21 Predator Vs. Black Panther #1 (Marvel Comics) 33 Deadpool Team-Up #1 (Marvel Comics) 34 EC Cruel Universe #1 (Oni Press) 42 Universal Monsters Frankenstein #1 (Of 4) (Image Comics) 45 Venom War: Spider-Man #1 (Venom War) (Marvel Comics) 49 DC Vs Vampires World War V #1 (Of 6) (DC Comics) 59 Power Fantasy #1 (Image Comics) 71 Phases of the Moon Knight #1 (Marvel Comics) 72 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Nightwatcher #1 (IDW Publishing) 73 Venom War: Carnage #1 (Venom War) (Marvel Comics) 74 Jenny Sparks #1 (Of 6) (DC Comics) 85 Blood Hunters #1 (Marvel Comics) 88 Venom War: Venomous #1 (Venom War) (Marvel Comics) 97 Jonny Quest #1 (Dynamite Ent.) 114 Ultraman X The Avengers #1 (Marvel Comics) 119 Giant-Size Thor #1 (Marvel Comics) 122 BRZRKR The Lost Book of B #1 (BOOM! Studios) 126 Venom War Zombiotes #1 (Venom War) (Marvel Comics) 127 Iron Fist 50th Anniversary Special #1 (Marvel Comics) 133 Chasm: Curse of Kaine #1 (Marvel Comics) 158 Hello Darkness #1 (BOOM! Studios) 168 Babs #1 (Of 6) (Ahoy Comics) 174 Garfield #1 (Of 4) (BOOM! Studios) 179 Eye Lie Popeye #1 (Sumerian Comics) 185 Arkham Horror: The Terror at the End of Time #1 (Dark Horse Comics) 197 Red Before Black #1 (Of 6) (BOOM! Studios) Unranked: Spidey and His Amazing Friends #1 (Marvel Comics) Unranked: C.O.W.L. 1964 #1 (Image Comics) Unranked: Cyber Force: Shootout #1 (Image Comics) Unranked: Standstill #1 (Image Comics) Unranked: Convert #1 (Image Comics) Unranked: Power Rangers: Infinity #1 (BOOM! Studios) Unranked: S.I.R. #1 (BOOM! Studios) Unranked: The Terminator: Suicide Run #1 (Dynamite Ent.) Unranked: Monster High: New Scaremester #1 (IDW Publishing) Unranked: My Little Pony: Best of Cutie Mark Crusaders #1 (IDW Publishing) Unranked: Rick and Morty: Finals Week – Contested Convention #1 (Oni Press) Unranked: Rick and Morty: Youth in Rickvolt #1 (Oni Press) Unranked: Sesame Street #1 (Oni Press) Unranked: Huge Detective #1 (Titan Comics)

Le numéro special thor ou iron fist.. c est pas ne reussite commerciale.
Je suis surpris par Werewolf assez haut et surtout Jenny Sparks assez bas...
Venom war ne prend pas dans ses tiens ins

	Citation:
	Big Events Venom War 5 Venom War #1 (Venom War) 43 Venom #36 (Venom War) 45 Venom War: Spider-Man #1 (Venom War) 73 Venom War: Carnage #1 (Venom War) 88 Venom War: Venomous #1 (Venom War) 126 Venom War Zombiotes #1 (Venom War) Venom War had one comic in the Top 10, one comic in the Top 25, and three comics in the Top 50. Venom War #1 had an impressive debut taking the number 5 spot. This five-issue mini-series from Al Ewing looks like it is going to be a sales hit. Having said that, while the main title in Venom War was a huge sales success, the tie-in titles all had unimpressive debut numbers. Absolute Power 4 Batman #151 (Absolute Power) 7 Absolute Power #2 (Of 4) 25 Wonder Woman #12 (Absolute Power) 27 Superman #17 (Absolute Power) 55 Green Lantern #14 (Absolute Power) Ezoic 62 Absolute Power Task Force VII #4 (Of 7) 107 Absolute Power Task Force VII #5 (Of 7) 129 Green Arrow #15 (Absolute Power) 130 Absolute Power Origins #2 (Of 3) 156 Absolute Power #1 (Of 4) (Resolicitation) 166 Absolute Power Task Force VII #3 (Of 7) (Resolicitation) Absolute Power had two comics in the Top 10, three comics in the Top 25, and four comics in the Top 50. This was better/worse/flat than July 2024 when Absolute Power had zero comics in the Top 10, three comics in the Top 25, and six comics in the Top 50. Absolute Power #2 climbed from the number 15 spot to the number 7 spot. This is what I expected from this four-issue big event. Absolute Power’s debut issue got caught up in an odd shipping schedule for the June 2024 and July 2024 rankings. I would expect Absolute Power to remain a Top 10 seller. Absolute Power Task Force VII #4 climbed from the number 98 spot to the number 62 spot. Absolute Power Task Force VII #5 then fell to the number 107 spot. Absolute Power Origins #2 fell from the number 88 spot to the number 130 spot. This three-issue mini-series has been a total sales failure. Everyone outside of a DC editor knew this was going to happen. John Ridley is a Hollywood guy who has never had sales success in mainstream superhero comics. And this title centers on Amanda Waller who is just not as popular as DC Comics thinks she is. Obviously, this mini-series will conclude well into the Dead Titles Walking category.

Absolute power est donc un succés le début était coincé entre 2 mois.
Venom wars sera un succés pour la mini mais n arrive pas a entrainer les tiens ins crées.

	Citation:
	Hasbro Franchise 8 Transformers #11 22 Scarlett #3 (Of 5) 32 Destro #3 (Of 5) 67 Void Rivals #12 87 Transformers #1 40th Anniversary Edition (One-Shot) 98 GI Joe A Real American Hero #309 176 Void Rivals #11 (Resolicitation) 187 Transformers #10 (Resolicitation)

La franchise Hasbro fonctionne bien chez Skybound..

	Citation:
	Spawn Franchise 89 Gunslinger Spawn #34 121 Spawn Scorched #32 144 Spawn Rat City #5 151 Spawn #355 (Resolicitation) 161 King Spawn #37 183 Spawn Misery #3 (Of 4) 195 Spawn Kills Every Spawn #2 (Of 5)

Je sais pas si ca suffira pour maintenir une franchise sur le long terme.

	Citation:
	Ghost Machine Titles 53 Geiger #5 75 Redcoat #5

Ca baisse chez Ghost Machine mais rien d alarmant les titres indés sont le plus souvent hors du top 100 ce sont les succés qui sont dans le top 100 (d où ma remarque pour hasbro)

	Citation:
	Star Wars Franchise 64 Star Wars: Darth Vader #49 90 Star Wars #49 115 Star Wars: Inquisitors #2 128 Star Wars: The High Republic (Phase III) #10 134 Star Wars: Ahsoka #2 160 Star Wars: Darth Maul – Black, White & Red #4 (Resolicitation) 170 Star Wars: Ahsoka #1 (Resolicitation) 200 Star Wars Darth Vader #48 (Resolicitation)

Pas sur que le marché STar Wars soit en floppy.. mais bon j en sais rien

	Citation:
	Captain America #12 plummeted from the number 43 spot to the number 140 spot. This is the lowest that we have seen this JMS title since it debuted.

On dirait que le titre plonge sous la periode Kelly/Lazing

Scarlet witch sort du TOP 75 (84)
je suis pas le seul à s interroger sur les eux relaunchs et leur effet... Orlando devait pas avoir eu un titre aussi vendeur que la première série...
Alors certes ca fera un long run en tout et un gain asuré pour Marvel. Mais je pense que le titre serait mieux classé sans ces artifices et que donc sur la longueur ca aurait ete mieux...

	Citation:
	Dead Titles Walking Based on historical numbers from the Comichron as well as projections through April 2022, titles outside of the Top 100 are usually selling under the 18,000 unit sales mark. These are the Marvel Comics and DC Comics titles that are dead titles walking. Marvel Comics 101 Sensational She-Hulk #10 103 Miles Morales Spider-Man Annual #1 104 Spider-Gwen: The Ghost-Spider #4 114 Ultraman X The Avengers #1 115 Star Wars: Inquisitors #2 116 Get Fury #4 119 Giant-Size Thor #1 120 Namor #2 124 Ghost Rider: Final Vengeance #6 126 Venom War Zombiotes #1 (Venom War) 127 Iron Fist 50th Anniversary Special #1 128 Star Wars: The High Republic (Phase III) #10 131 Incredible Hulk Annual #1 (Infinity Watch) 133 Chasm: Curse of Kaine #1 134 Star Wars: Ahsoka #2 135 Daredevil: Woman Without Fear #2 140 Captain America #12 141 Venomverse Reborn #3 154 Venom Separation Anxiety #4 167 Spider-Woman #10 Unranked: Spidey and His Amazing Friends #1 Unranked: Marvel 85th Anniversary Special #1 Marvel Comics had twenty-one dead titles walking out of their seventy-one new titles in August 2024. This means that 30% of Marvel Comics’ new titles in August 2024 were dead titles walking. This was up from the eighteen dead titles walking that Marvel Comics had in July 2024 which comprised 28% of Marvel Comics’ new titles. Year-over-year numbers were down as Marvel Comics had twenty-six dead titles walking in August 2023. This comprised 34% of Marvel Comics’ new titles in August 2023. Numbers were down from two years ago as Marvel Comics had thirty-two dead titles walking in August 2022. This comprised 35% of Marvel Comics’ new titles in August 2022. Numbers were flat from three years ago as Marvel Comics had twenty-one dead titles walking in August 2021. DC Comics 107 Absolute Power Task Force VII #5 (Of 7) 109 The Boy Wonder #4 (Of 5) 110 Nice House by the Sea #2 (Of 12) 129 Green Arrow #15 (Absolute Power) 130 Absolute Power Origins #2 (Of 3) 138 The Flash #12 139 Batman Off-World #5 (Of 6) 146 Batman Dark Age #5 (Of 6) 148 Green Lantern War Journal #12 150 John Constantine, Hellblazer Dead in America #8 (Of 11) 152 Shazam #14 163 Power Girl #12 165 Zero Hour 30th Anniversary Special #1 (One-Shot) 189 My Adventures with Superman #3 (Of 6) 194 Outsiders #10 196 Kneel Before Zod #8 (Of 8) 199 Batman the Brave and the Bold #16 Unranked: Blue Beetle #11 Unranked: Primer: Clashing Colors #2 Unranked: The Batman and Scooby-Doo Mysteries #8 Unranked: Batman and Robin and Howard: Summer Breakdown #2 Unranked: Scooby-Doo, Where Are You? #129 DC Comics had twenty-two dead titles walking out of DC Comics’ forty-six new titles in August 2024. This means that 48% of the new DC Comics titles in August 2023 were dead titles walking. This was way up from the twelve dead titles walking that DC Comics had in July 2024 which comprised 35% of DC Comics’ new titles. Year-over-year numbers were down as DC Comics had thirty dead titles walking in August 2023. This comprised 51% of DC Comics’ new titles in August 2023. Numbers were down from two years ago as DC Comics had thirty-one dead titles walking in August 2022. This comprised 49% of DC Comics’ new titles in August 2022. Numbers were down from three years ago as DC Comics had thirty dead titles walking in August 2021. Image Comics 105 Ain’t No Grave #4 (Of 5) 106 Deviant #7 (Of 9) 121 Spawn Scorched #32 132 Witchblade #2 144 Spawn Rat City #5 145 Falling in Love on the Path to Hell #3 157 The Walking Dead Deluxe #94 161 King Spawn #37 183 Spawn Misery #3 (Of 4) 186 The Walking Dead Deluxe #95 188 Grommets #4 (Of 7) 195 Spawn Kills Every Spawn #2 (Of 5) Unranked: Ain’t No Grave #4 Unranked: C.O.W.L. 1964 #1 Unranked: Cyber Force: Shootout #1 Unranked: The Deviant #7 Unranked: Free Agents #2 Unranked: Kaya #20 Unranked: Mike Andolfo’s Sweet Paprika: Black, White, & Pink #2 Unranked: Public Domain #7 Unranked: The Domain #2 Unranked: Falling in Love on the Path to Hell #3 Unranked: Napalm Lullaby #6 Unranked: Precious Metal #3 Unranked: Rifters #3 Unranked: Black Cloak #7 Unranked: Blood Squad Seven #4 Unranked: Local Man #13 Unranked: Plastic: Death & Dolls #3 Unranked: Self Help #3 Unranked: Standstill #1 Unranked: The Walking Dead Deluxe #95 Unranked: Convert #1 Unranked: Drawing Blood #5 Unranked: Killadelphia #35 Unranked: The Last Mermaid #6 Unranked: Monstress #54 Unranked: Nights #10 Unranked: Remote Spaces #3 Unranked: Rogue Sun #21 Unranked: The Sacrificers #11 Image Comics had forty-one dead titles walking out of Image Comics’ fifty-four new titles in August 2024. This means that 76% of the new Image Comics titles in August 2023 were dead titles walking. This was up from the thirty-nine dead titles that Image Comics had in July 2024 which comprised 75% of Image Comics’ new titles. This highlights the importance of profitable licenses from Hasbro and Universal since all of the other random indie titles from Image Comics fail to even make the Top 200. Image Comics took third place with twenty-five new comics in the Top 200 in August 2024. BOOM! Studios 122 BRZRKR The Lost Book of B #1 142 Hello Darkness #2 174 Garfield #1 184 Something is Killing the Children #39 197 Red Before Black #1 198 Vicious Circle #3 Unranked: Ranger Academy #9 Unranked: Power Rangers: Infinity #1 Unranked: Jim Henson’s The Dark Crystal: Archive Edition #2 Unranked: The Armory Wars: Good Apollo, I’m Bruning Star IV, Volume II #4 Unranked: Profane #3 Unranked: S.I.R. #1 Unranked: Blow Away #5 Unranked: Briar #8 Unranked: Crodocile Black #4 Unranked: Lawful #3 Unranked: Dune: House Corrino #5 Unranked: Once & Future: Pen & Ink #1 BOOM! Studios had eighteen dead titles walking out of BOOM! Studios’ nineteen new titles in August 2024. This means that 95% of the new BOOM! Studios titles in August 2023 were dead titles walking. It is disappointing to see how poorly the Power Rangers titles are performing. The Power Rangers should be a valuable license. One needs to only look over at Image Comics, Dynamite Entertainment, and IDW Publishing to see how properties from the 1960s-1990s can perform well in the Top 200. Having said that, I am not surprised that the two Power Rangers titles are dead titles walking. The farther BOOM! Studios gets away from the classic Power Rangers and the more “modern” their take on the Power Rangers gets the less popular it will become. Power Rangers: Infinity #1 failing to even debut in the Top 200 is a total disaster. This is no surprise as this comic looked as cringe as possible. BOOM! Studios took fourth place with seven new comics in the Top 200 in August 2024. Dynamite Entertainment 123 ThunderCats Cheetara #2 Unranked: Hercules #4 Unranked: Vampirella: Dark Reflections #3 Unranked: Red Sonja: Empire of the Damned #5 Unranked: Vampirella #671 Unranked: Darkwing Duck: Justice Ducks #5 Unranked: The Powerpuff Girls #2 Unranked: Darkwing Duck: Negaduck #7 Unranked: The Terminator: Suicide Run #1 Dynamite Entertainment had nine dead titles walking out of Dynamite Entertainment’s twelve new titles in August 2024. This means that 75% of the new Dynamite Entertainment titles in August 2023 were dead titles walking. Dynamite Entertainment took fifth place with four new comics in the Top 200 in August 2024. Titan Comics 102 Conan The Barbarian #14 111 Gun Honey Collision Course #4 162 Savage Sword of Conan #4 (Of 6) 191 Conan The Barbarian #13 (Resolicitation) Unranked: Doctor Who: The Fifteenth Doctor #2 Unranked: Elric: The Necromancer #2 Unranked: High on Life #3 Unranked: Life is Strange: Forget-Me-Not #4 Unranked: Huge Detective #1 Unranked: Rivers of London: Stray Cat Blues #4 Unranked: Blade Runner: Tokyo Nexus #2 Unranked: Nouns: Nountown #2 Unranked: Star Wars Insider #227 Titan Comics had twelve dead titles walking out of Titan Comics’ twelve new titles in August 2024. This means that 100% of the new Titan Comics titles in August 2023 were dead titles walking. The Conan license continues to be a sales blessing to Titan Comics. The Gun Honey franchise also continues to be a solid seller for Titan Comics. Titan Comics tied for sixth place with three new comics in the Top 200. IDW Publishing 171 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Black White & Green #4 177 Godzilla: Here There Be Dragons II–Sons of Giants #2 Unranked: Monster High: New Scaremester #1 Unranked: My Little Pony: Best of Cutie Mark Crusaders #1 Unranked: My Little Pony: Maretime Mysteries #3 Unranked: My Little Pony: Set Your Sail #5 Unranked: Stark Trek #23 Unranked: Star Trek: Defiant #18 Unranked: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Saturday Morning Adventures #16 Unranked: The Hunger and the Dusk: Book Two #2 The Rocketeer: Breaks Free #2 Sonic the Hedgehog #72 IDW Publishing had twelve dead titles walking out of IDW Publishing’s thirteen new titles in August 2024. This means that 92% of the new IDW Publishing’s titles in August 2023 were dead titles walking. My Little Pony franchise appears to be dead in the water with all three titles from that franchise going unranked. Even more concerning is that the Star Trek license appears to be useless in the hands of IDW Publishing. Both Star Trek titles went unranked. IDW Publishing continues its trend of fumbling its licenses. The best move Hasbro made was pulling their license from IDW Publishing. IDW Publishing tied for sixth place with three new comics in the Top 200 in August 2024. Oni Press Unranked: Rick and Morty: Finals Week – Contested Convention #1 Unranked: Rick and Morty: Youth in Rickvolt #1 Unranked: Biker Mice from Mars #2 Unranked: Cult of the Lamb #3 Unranked: Akogun: Brutalizer of Gods #3 Unranked: Sesame Street #1 Oni Press had six dead titles walking out of Oni Press’ eight new titles in August 2024. This means that 75% of the new Oni Press titles in August 2023 were dead titles walking. Oni Press took eighth place with two new comics in the Top 200. Both were EC titles.

Bon je relativiserai tout en disant que le TOP 100 est surtout historiquement un plancher pour Marvel.
DC laissait certains titres dont vertigo presque au porte du top 200 et pour les indés.. j ai jamais connu le plancher.

Coté Marvel Namor doit etre une deception.. Chez DC Green Arrow ne decolle pas malgré Absolute Power.. Flash..

[Fred le mallrat]

Top 50 de Septembre
https://icv2.com/articles/markets/vi...september-2024
Plus d'éléments
https://www.comicbookrevolution.com/...ales-rankings/

	Citation:
	Debut Issues 1 Wolverine #1 (Marvel Comics) 4 Exceptional X-Men #1 (Marvel Comics) 8 DC All-In Special #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics) 15 Dazzler #1 (Marvel Comics) 16 Batman the Long Halloween: The Last Halloween #1 (Of 10) (DC Comics) 25 Storm #1 (Marvel Comics) 30 Aliens Vs. Avengers #1 (Marvel Comics) 34 Marvel & Disney What If…? Donald Duck Became Thor #1 (Marvel Comics) 42 Spirits of Vengeance #1 (Marvel Comics) 47 Minor Arcana #1 (BOOM! Studios) 49 Avengers Assemble #1 (Marvel Comics) 55 Venom War: Wolverine #1 (Venom War) (Marvel Comics) 58 Moon is Following Us #1 (Of 10) (Image Comics) 71 Plastic Man No More #1 (Of 4) (DC Comics) 83 Absolute Power Super Son #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics) 85 Spawn Violator #1 (Of 6) (Image Comics) 87 Star Wars: The Acolyte – Kelnacca #1 (Marvel Comics) 88 Venom War: Deadpool #1 (Venom War) (Marvel Comics) 91 Conan the Barbarian Battle of the Blackstone #1 (Of 4) (Titan Comics) 94 Universal Monsters Frankenstein #1 (Of 4) (Image Comics) 102 Hyde Street #1 (Image Comics) 113 Batman Day 2024 – Batman Elmer Fudd Special #1 (DC Comics) 115 Marvel Zombies: Dawn of Decay #1 (Marvel Comics) 117 Masters of the Universe/Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Turtles of Grayskull #1 (Dark Horse Comics) 131 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Nation #1 (IDW Publishing) 139 Ghost Rider: Robbie Reyes Special #1 (Marvel Comics) 145 Lobo Cancellation Special #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics) 148 Creepshow Vol. 3 #1 (Of 5) (Image Comics) 149 Star Wars: The Battle of Jakku #1 Insurgency Rising (Marvel Comics) 150 Venom War: Lethal Protectors #1 (Venom War) (Marvel Comics) 156 Lilith #1 (Of 5) (Vault Comics) 158 Multiversus Collision Detection #1 (Of 6) (DC Comics) 172 Deathlok 50th Anniversary Special #1 (Marvel Comics) 179 Knights Vs Samurai #1 (Image Comics) 181 Venom War Daredevil #1 (Venom War) (Marvel Comics) 193 Time Waits #1 (Of 4) (DSTLRY) 194 Graveyard Club #1 (Of 2) (BOOM! Studios) 199 Missionary #1 (Of 3) (DSTLRY) 200 DC Horror Presents Creature Commandos #1 (Of 6) (DC Comics) Unranked: Spider-Man: Homeroom Heroes #1 (Marvel Comics) Unranked: Trinity Special: World’s Finest #1 (DC Comics) Unranked: DC’s I Know What You Did Last Crisis #1 (DC Comics) Unranked: Batman / Elmer Fudd Batman Day Special Edition #1 (DC Comics) Unranked: Batman / Elmer Fudd Batman Day Noir Special Edition #1 (DC Comics) Unranked: Lady Mechanika: The Devil in the Lake #1 (Image Comics) Unranked: Dead Eyes: The Empty Frames #1 (Image Comics) Unranked: The Tin Can Society #1 (Image Comics) Unranked: The Horizon Experiment: The Manchurian #1 (Image Comics) Unranked: Old Dog: Operations #1 (Image Comics) Unranked: Violent Flowers #1 (Image Comics) Unranked: Red Sonja: Death and the Devil #1 (Dynamite Ent.) Unranked: Barbarella #1 (Dynamite Ent.) Unranked: Jim Henson’s Labyrinth #1 (BOOM! Studios) Unranked: The Creeping Below #1 (BOOM! Studios) As usual, we will address most of these debut issues in their respective franchise sections below. However, there is one that we will touch on at this point. DC Horror Presents Creature Commandos #1 scored an embarrassingly awful debut with the number 200 spot. This six-issue limited series is almost a lock to be unranked with just the second issue. David Dastmalchian is the writer for this mini-series. While Dastmalchian is an excellent actor, what he is not is a mainstream superhero comic book writer. Once again, the weird obsession that both DC Comics and Marvel Comics have for hiring Hollywood talent to write comics completely blows up in DC Comics’ face.

Les mutants se portent bien. Pas mal pour DC all in.. Lobo on est pas pret de voir une mini ou une serie.. avengers assemble part mal

	Citation:
	Big Events Venom War 18 Venom War #2 (Venom War) 31 Venom #37 (Venom War) 55 Venom War: Wolverine #1 (Venom War) 62 Venom War #3 (Venom War) 88 Venom War: Deadpool #1 (Venom War) 89 Venom War: Spider-Man #2 (Venom War) 132 Venom War: Carnage #2 (Venom War) 133 Venom War: Venomous #2 (Venom War) 150 Venom War: Lethal Protectors #1 (Venom War) 177 Venom War: Spider-Man #3 (Venom War) 180 Venom War Zombiotes #2 (Venom War) 181 Venom War Daredevil #1 (Venom War) 191 Venom War #1 (Venom War) (Resolicitation) Venom War had zero comics in the Top 10, one comic in the Top 25, and two comics in the Top 50. This was worse than in August 2024 when Venom War had one comic in the Top 10, one comic in the Top 25, and three comics in the Top 50. Venom War #2 fell from the number 5 spot to the number 18 spot. Venom War #3 fell from the number 18 spot to the number 62 spot. It is tough when a title ships two issues in the same sales period. I expect Venom War #4 to rebound into the Top 50 next month. Venom War: Wolverine #1 debuted poorly at the number 55 spot. This three-issue limited series is going to have to fight to stay in the Top 75. Venom War: Deadpool #1 had an awful debut taking the number 88 spot. This three-issue mini-series had a tough road ahead to finish outside the Dead Titles Walking category. Venom War: Spider-Man #2 plummeted from the number 45 spot to the number 89 spot. This is not a surprise given the weak debut number. Jackson Lanzig and Collin Kelly have yet another sales failure despite being paired up with the human ATM known as Peter Parker. Venom War: Spider-Man #3 crashed and burned falling from the number 89 spot to the number 177 spot. No doubt that it is tough shipping two issues in the same sale period, but Venom War: Spider-Man is a lock to conclude in the Dead Titles Walking category with the fourth and final issue. Venom War: Carnage #2 dropped from the number 73 spot to the number 132 spot. Given the bad debut number, I figured that this would happen. Torunn Grømbekk failed to get readers excited about this Venom War tie-in mini-series. This title is a lock to finish in the Dead Titles Walking category. Venom War: Venomous #2 fell from the number 88 spot to the number 133 spot. Erica Schultz continues to have no sales success. Readers certainly were not enticed by the prospect of a Venomized Black Widow. This three-issue mini-series will conclude as a Dead Title Walking. Venom War: Lethal Protectors #1 had a brutal debut at the number 150 spot. Wow. We all saw this coming. Sabir Pirzada is the writer and has never had any sales success. Once again, hiring a Hollywood screenwriter to pen a mainstream superhero comic book blows up in Marvel Comics’ face. Yet, like a mindless idiot, Marvel Comics editorial will continue to pull out this same trick in the future. The big question is if this three-issue mini-series will be ranked in the Top 200. Venom War Zombiotes #2 plummeted from the number 126 spot to the number 180 spot. This four-issue mini-series has a good chance of concluding outside the Top 200. Cavan Scott continues his trend of having no sales success. Venom War Daredevil #1 had a godawful debut barely even getting ranked and taking the number 181 spot. What an embarrassing debut. Nobody was interested in Christopher Condon’s one-shot issue. The main Venom War title has been a solid seller. But, the Venom War mini-series have all been unmitigated disasters. The biggest reason for that is due to Marvel Comics hiring an awful collection of writers for the Venom War mini-series. Absolute Power 6 Batman #152 (Absolute Power) 10 Absolute Power #3 (Of 4) 21 Absolute Power #4 (Of 4) 23 Wonder Woman #13 (Absolute Power) 28 Superman #18 (Absolute Power) 54 Green Lantern #15 (Absolute Power) 72 Absolute Power Task Force VII #6 (Of 7) 83 Absolute Power Super Son #1 (One-Shot) 93 Absolute Power Task Force VII #7 (Of 7) 122 Green Arrow #16 (Absolute Power) 152 Absolute Power Origins #3 (Of 3) Absolute Power had one comic in the Top 10, three comics in the Top 25, and four comics in the Top 50. This was worse in the Top 10 but flat in the Top 25 and Top 50 compared to August 2024 when Absolute Power had two comics in the Top 10, three comics in the Top 25, and four comics in the Top 50. Absolute Power #3 fell from the number 7 spot to the number 10 spot. Absolute Power #4 fell from the number 10 spot to the number 21 spot. It is embarrassing when the main big event title gets outsold by a tie-in issue. Still, Absolute Power was a good selling big event for DC Comics. It would have been more impressive is all four issues managed to finish in the Top 10. But, slotting two of the four issues in the Top 10 is still a good accomplishment. Absolute Power Task Force VII #6 bounced up from the number 107 spot to the number 72 spot. Absolute Power Task Force VII #7 fell from the number 72 spot to the number 93 spot. This tie-in title was a sales disappointment. But, at least it finished outside of the Dead Titles Walking category. Absolute Power Origins #3 fell from the number 130 spot to the number 152 spot. With this issue, this mini-series concludes. Nobody was interested in an origin story of Amanda Waller from John Ridley. Once again, a Hollywood screenwriter finds no success writing a mainstream superhero comic.

La franchise Hasbro est une réussite. Ghost machine se porte bien. L univers Ultimate est dans le top 25

L ensemble des séries mutantes se classent dans le top 60.. un bon début.


Les titres en danger!!
Bon attention car la regle du top 100 s apllique surtout à Marvel et dans une moindre mesure à DC (qui laissait ses titres vertigos ou kids bien plus bas).
Pour les autres editeurs s etaient un peu leur classement normal donc..

	Citation:
	Dead Titles Walking Based on historical numbers from the Comichron as well as projections through April 2022, titles outside of the Top 100 are usually selling under the 18,000 unit sales mark. These are the Marvel Comics and DC Comics titles that are dead titles walking. Marvel Comics 101 Captain America #13 104 Spider-Society #2 105 Scarlet Witch #4 114 Werewolf by Night Red Band #2 115 Marvel Zombies: Dawn of Decay #1 118 Kid Venom #2 120 Moon Knight Annual #1 (Infinity Watch) 121 Daredevil #14 123 Get Fury #5 127 Deadpool Team-Up #2 129 Immortal Thor #16 132 Venom War: Carnage #2 (Venom War) 133 Venom War: Venomous #2 (Venom War) 134 Wolverine: Deep Cut #3 136 Venomverse Reborn #4 139 Ghost Rider: Robbie Reyes Special #1 147 Star Wars: Inquisitors #3 149 Star Wars: The Battle of Jakku #1 Insurgency Rising 150 Venom War: Lethal Protectors #1 (Venom War) 153 Venom: Separation Anxiety #5 161 Spider-Gwen: The Ghost-Spider #6 168 Blood Hunters #2 170 Spider-Boy Annual #1 (Infinity Watch) 172 Deathlok 50th Anniversary Special #1 177 Venom War: Spider-Man #3 (Venom War) 178 Star Wars: Ahsoka #3 180 Venom War Zombiotes #2 (Venom War) 181 Venom War Daredevil #1 (Venom War) 189 Daredevil: Woman Without Fear #3 198 Chasm: Curse of Kaine #2 Unranked: Namor #3 Unranked: Get Fury #6 Unranked: Star Wars: Inquisitors #4 Unranked: Ultraman X Avengers #2 Unranked: Wolverine: Deep Cut #4 Unranked: Spider-Man: Homeroom Heroes #1 Marvel Comics had thirty-six dead titles walking out of their eighty-eight new titles in September 2024. This means that 41% of Marvel Comics’ new titles in September 2024 were dead titles walking. This was up from the twenty-one dead titles walking that Marvel Comics had in August 2024 which comprised 30% of Marvel Comics’ new titles. Year-over-year numbers were up as Marvel Comics had twenty dead titles walking in September 2023. This comprised 26% of Marvel Comics’ new titles in September 2023. Numbers were up two years ago as Marvel Comics had fifteen dead titles walking in September 2022. This comprised 21% of Marvel Comics’ new titles in September 2022. DC Comics 103 Batman and Robin #13 107 Dark Knights of Steel Allwinter #3 (Of 6) 110 Titans #15 112 From the DC Vault Death in the Family Robin Lives! #3 (Of 4) 113 Batman Day 2024 – Batman Elmer Fudd Special #1 116 Catwoman #68 119 Batman ’89 Echoes #4 (Of 6) 122 Green Arrow #16 (Absolute Power) 135 The Boy Wonder #5 (Of 5) 138 Poison Ivy #26 144 The Flash #13 145 Lobo Cancellation Special #1 (One-Shot) 151 John Constantine, Hellblazer Dead in America #9 (Of 11) 152 Absolute Power Origins #3 (Of 3) 154 Justice Society of America #12 (Of 12) 158 Multiversus Collision Detection #1 (Of 6) 159 Birds of Prey #14 163 Jenny Sparks #2 (Of 6) 166 Nice House by the Sea #3 (Of 12) 171 Penguin #12 182 Harley Quinn #43 184 Plastic Man No More #2 (Of 4) 200 DC Horror Presents Creature Commandos #1 (Of 6) Unranked: Outsiders #11 Unranked: Power Girl #13 Unranked: Shazam! #15 Unranked: Shazam! #16 Unranked: My Adventures with Superman #4 Unranked: My Adventures with Superman #5 Unranked: Trinity Special: World’s Finest #1 Unranked: Batman: The Brave and the Bold #17 Unranked: The Batman & Scooby-Doo Mysteries #9 Unranked: Scooby-Doo, Where Are You? #130 Unranked: Batman and Robin and Howard: Summer Breakdown #3 Unranked: DC’s I Know What You Did Last Crisis #1 Unranked: Batman / Elmer Fudd Batman Day Noir Special Edition #1 Unranked: Looney Tunes #280 Unranked: Primer: Clashing Colors #3 Unranked: MultiVersus: Collision Detected #2 DC Comics had thirty-nine dead titles walking out of DC Comics’ sixty-two new titles in September 2024. This means that 63% of the new DC Comics titles in September 2024 were dead titles walking. This was up from the twenty-two dead titles walking that DC Comics had in August 2024 which comprised 48% of DC Comics’ new titles. Year-over-year numbers were up as DC Comics had nineteen dead titles walking in September 2023. This comprised 38% of DC Comics’ new titles in September 2023. Numbers were up from two years ago as DC Comics had twenty-five dead titles walking in September 2022. This comprised 45% of DC Comics’ new titles in September 2022. Image Comics 11 Transformers #12 26 Scarlett #4 (Of 5) 37 Destro #4 (Of 5) 45 Rook Exodus #5 48 Saga #69 58 Moon is Following Us #1 (Of 10) 66 Universal Monsters Frankenstein #2 (Of 4) 67 Geiger #6 (2024) 70 Spawn #356 85 Spawn Violator #1 (Of 6) 90 Saga #68 (Resolictation) 94 Universal Monsters Frankenstein #1 (Of 4) 102 Hyde Street #1 106 Department of Truth #25 108 Gunslinger Spawn #35 109 GI Joe A Real American Hero #310 111 Feral #6 125 Ain’t No Grave #5 (Of 5) 140 Power Fantasy #2 142 Redcoat #6 148 Creepshow Vol. 3 #1 (Of 5) 165 Spawn Scorched #33 166 Nice House by the Sea #3 (Of 12) (DC Comics) 167 Witchblade #3 (2024) 176 Transformers #1 40th Anniversary Edition (One-Shot) 179 Knights vs Samurai #1 188 Spawn #357 192 Spawn Rat City #6 Unranked: King Spawn #38 Unranked: Misery #3 Unranked: Sam and Twitch: Case Files #6 Unranked: Free Agents #3 Unranked: Free Agents #4 Unranked: Holly Roller #8 Unranked: Infernals #5 Unranked: Lady Mechanika: The Devil in the Lake #1 Unranked: Public Domain #8 Unranked: The Walking Dead Deluxe #96 Unranked: The Walking Dead Deluxe #97 Unranked: The Walking Dead Deluxe #98 Unranked: Dead Eyes: The Empty Frames #1 Unranked: The Domain #3 Unranked: Precious Metal #4 Unranked: C.O.W.L. 1964 #2 Unranked: Falling in Love on the Path to Hell #4 Unranked: Ice Cream Man #41 Unranked: The Tin Can Society #1 Unranked: Ultramega #5 Unranked: Black Cloak #8 Unranked: Convert #2 Unranked: Drawing Blood #6 Unranked: The Horizon Experiment: The Manchurian #1 Unranked: Kaya #21 Unranked: Moon Man #4 Unranked: Nights #11 Unranked: Old Dog: Operations #1 Unranked: Plastic: Death & Dolls #4 Unranked: Purr Evil #6 Unranked: Remote Space #4 Unranked: Rifters #4 Unranked: Rogue Sun #22 Unranked: Self Help #4 Unranked: Spawn Kills Every Spawn #3 Unranked: Standstill #2 Unranked: Violent Flowers #1 Unranked: The Deviant #8 Unranked: I Hate Fairyland #16 Unranked: Savage Dragon #272 Image Comics had fifty-six dead titles walking out of Image Comics’ sixty-seven new titles in September 2024. This means that 84% of the new Image Comics titles in September 2024 were dead titles walking. This was up from the forty-one dead titles that Image Comics had in August 2024 which comprised 76% of Image Comics’ new titles. Image Comics took third place with twenty-eight new comics in the Top 200 in September 2024. BOOM! Studios 47 Minor Arcana #1 143 Hello Darkness #3 164 Animal Pound #5 (Of 5) 169 Something is Killing the Children #40 194 Graveyard Club #1 (Of 2) 196 BRZRKR The Lost Book of B #1 (Resolicitation) Unranked: Power Rangers Academy #10 Unranked: Power Rangers Academy #11 Unranked: Mighty Morphin Power Rangers/Usagi Yojimbo #1 Unranked: Farscape: 25th Anniversary Special #1 Unranked: Farscape: Archived Edition #1 Unranked: Firefly: Malcolm Reynolds Year One #1 Unranked: Uncanny Valley #5 Unranked: The Armory Wars: Good Apollo, I’m Bruning Star IV, Volume II #5 Unranked: Garfield #2 Unranked: Profane #4 Unranked: Red Before Black #2 Unranked: Jim Henson’s Labyrinth #1 Unranked: Lawful #4 Unranked: S.I.R. #2 Unranked: Dune: House Corrino #6 Unranked: The Creeping Below #1 BOOM! Studios had twenty-one dead titles walking out of BOOM! Studios’ twenty-two new titles in September 2024. This means that 95% of the new BOOM! Studios titles in September 2024 were dead titles walking. This was flat compared to the eighteen dead titles that BOOM! Studios had in August 2024 which comprised 95% of BOOM! Studios’ new titles. BOOM! Studios came in fourth place with six new comics in the Top 200 in September 2024. Dynamite Entertainment 74 Space Ghost #5 128 ThunderCats #8 197 Jonny Quest #2 Unranked: ThunderCats: Cheetara #3 Unranked: Army of Darkness Forever #11 Unranked: Army of Darkness Forever #12 Unranked: Red Sonja #13 Unranked: Red Sonja #14 Unranked: Red Sonja: Death and the Devil #1 Unranked: Red Sonja: Death and the Devil #12 Unranked: Barbarella #1 Unranked: Sweetie Candy Vigilante #4 Unranked: Vampirella: Dark Reflections #4 Unranked: Vampirella: Dark Reflections #5 Unranked: Disney Villains: Cruella De Vil #5 Unranked: Fiire and Ice #3 Unranked: Darkwing Duck: Negaduck #8 Unranked: Hercules #5 Unranked: Lilo & Stich #5 Unranked: The Powerpuff Girls #3 Dynamite Entertainment had twenty dead titles walking out of Dynamite Entertainment’s twenty-one new titles in September 2024. This means that 95% of the new Dynamite Entertainment titles in September 2024 were dead titles walking. This was up from the nine dead titles that Dynamite Comics had in August 2024 which comprised 75% of Dynamite Comics’ new titles. Dynamite Entertainment tied for fifth place with three new comics in the Top 200 in September 2024. IDW Publishing 13 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #2 131 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Nation #1 187 Godzilla Vs. The Mighty Morphin Power Rangers II #5 Unranked: Godzilla: Skate or Die #3 Unranked: Godzilla: Skate or Die #4 Unranked: Godzilla Rivals: Mechagodzilla vs. King Ghidorah #1 Unranked: Godzilla: Here There Be Dragons II – Sons of Giants #3 Unranked: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Sourcebooks #4 Unranked: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Saturday Morning Adventures #17 Unranked: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Nightwattcher #2 Unranked: TMNT: Best of – Dark Leo #1 Unranked: My Little Pony: Maretime Mysteries #4 Unranked: My Little Pony: The Storm of Zephyr Heights #1 Unranked: Sonic the Hedgehog #73 Unranked: Star Trek #500 Unranked: Star Trek #24 Unranked: Star Trek: Defiant #19 Unranked: Monster High: New Scaremester #2 IDW Publishing had seventeen dead titles walking out of IDW Publishing’s eighteen new titles in September 2024. This means that 94% of the new IDW Publishing’s titles in September 2024 were dead titles walking. This was up from the twelve dead titles that IDW Publishing had in August 2024 which comprised 92% of IDW Publishing’s new titles. IDW Publishing tied for fifth place with three new comics in the Top 200 in September 2024. Dark Horse Comics 117 Masters of the Universe/Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Turtles of Grayskull #1 124 Helen of Wyndhorn #4 173 Helen of Wyndhorn #5 Unranked: Masters of the Universe: Revolution #4 Unranked: Arkham Horror: The Terror at the End of Time #2 Unranked: Canto: A Place Like Home #4 Unranked: Dawnrunner #5 Unranked: Duck and Cover #1 Unranked: Grendel: Devil’s Crucible – Defiance #3 Unranked: Star Wars: The High Republic Adventures – Crash and Burn #1 Unranked: Star Wars: The High Republic Adventures – Echoes of Fear #1 Unranked: Star Wars: The High Republic Adventures #10 Unranked: Usagi Yojimbo: 40th Anniversary Chanoyu Convention Exclusive #1 Unranked: Groo: Minstrel Melodies #1 Unranked: Into the Unbeing #4 Unranked: Midst: The Valorous Farmer #1 Unranked: The Oddly Pedestrian Life of Christopher Chaos #12 Unranked: Prodigy: Slaves of Mars #2 Unranked: Summer Shadows #1 Unranked: The Witcher: Crovo Blanco #4 Unranked: Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora #6 Unranked: Beyond the Pale #4 Unranked: Gilt Frame #2 Unranked: Joy Operations 2 #4 Unranked: The Masked Macher #1 Unranked: Paraqnoid Gardens #3 Unranked: Tiny Tina’s Wonderlands: Land of the Giants #2 Unranked: The Writer #3 Unranked: Anansi Boys #4 Unranked: Cyberpunk 2077: Kickdown #3 Unranked: Kill All Immortals #3 Unranked: The Magic Order 5 #31 Unranked: Night Club 2 #2 Unranked: ‘Patra #2 Unranked: Resident Alien: The Book of Life #4 Unranked: Survival Street: The Radical Left #1 Unranked: Nemesis: Rogues’ Gallery #3 Dark Horse Comics had thirty-seven dead titles walking out of Dark Horse Comics’ thirty-seven new titles in September 2024. This means that 100% of the new Dark Horse Comics titles in September 2024 were dead titles walking. This was flat compared to twelve dead titles that Dark Horse Comics had in August 2024 which comprised 100% of Dark Horse Comics’ new titles. Dark Horse Comics tied for fifth place with three new comics in the Top 200 in September 2024. DSTLRY 193 Time Waits #1 (Of 4) 199 Missionary #1 (Of 3) Unranked: Somna Cover Gallery #1 Unraenkd: Blasfamous: Cover Gallery #1 Unranked: Gone Cover Gallery #1 Unranked: Gone: Local Comics Shop Day Edition #1 Unranked: The Blood Brothers Mother #2 Unranked: The Missionary: Red Label Edition #1 Unranked: Spectregraph #3 DSTLRY had nine dead titles walking out of DSTLRY’s nine new titles in September 2024. This means that 100% of the new DSTLRY titles in September 2024 were dead titles walking. DSTLRY tied for eighth place with two new comics in the Top 200 in September 2024. Oni Press 95 EC Epitaphs from the Abyss #3 (Of 5) 100 EC Cruel Universe #2 (Of 5) Unranked: EC Cruel Universe #3 Unranked: The Autumn Kingdom #1 Unranked: Toxic Summer #3 Unranked: Rick and Morty: Touth in Rickvolt #2 Unranked: Rick and Morty: Rick or Treat Halloween Special #1 Unranked: Biker Mice from Mars #3 Unranked: Cult of the Lamb #4 Unranked: Sesame Street #2 Unranked: Skin Police #1 Oni Press had ten dead titles walking out of Oni Press’ eleven new titles in September 2024. This means that 91% of the new Oni Press titles in September 2024 were dead titles walking. This was up from the six dead titles that Oni Press had in August 2024 which comprised 75% of Oni Press’ new titles. Oni Press tied for eighth place with two new comics in the Top 200 in September 2024. Vault Comics 156 Lilith #1 (Of 5) Unranked: Goobers #1 Unranked: Something Crawled Out #2 Vault Comics had three dead titles walking out of Vault Comics’ three new titles in September 2024. This means that 100% of the new Vault Comics titles in September 2024 were dead titles walking. Vault Comics came in tenth place with one new comic in the Top 200 in September 2024.

Captain America est toujours hors du top 100.. un crash!
Attention avec dd ou Immortal Thor qui ont du sortir enb fin de mois car Immortal thor est aussi dans le top 50

[scarletneedle]

DC va sûrement arrêter des titres pour laisser de la place aux nouveaux Absolute.

[Fred le mallrat]

Top 50 D'octobre
Les titres absolute se portent bien et on remis DC All in dans le top ce qui fait qu au final le titre a marché comme il faut. On se souvient que DC a du reinsister sur ce titre, ils ont bien fait.

	Citation:
	Debut Issues 1 Absolute Batman #1 (DC Comics) 2 Absolute Wonder Woman #1 (DC Comics) 8 Iron Man #1 (Marvel Comics) 12 Moon Knight: Fist of Khonshu #1 (Marvel Comics) 14 Batman and Robin Year One #1 (Of 12) (DC Comics) 17 Batman Full Moon #1 (Of 4) (DC Comics) 18 Blade: Red Band #1 (Marvel Comics) 22 Terminator #1 (Dynamite Ent.) 26 Mystique #1 (Marvel Comics) 39 Sentinels #1 (Marvel Comics) 46 Alien: Romulus #1 (Marvel Comics) 53 Green Lantern Civil Corps Special #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics) 56 Green Lantern Dark #1 (Of 7) (DC Comics) 62 DC Horror Presents #1 (Of 3) (DC Comics) 69 Crypt of Shadows #1 (Marvel Comics) 70 Star Wars: Ewoks #1 (Marvel Comics) 88 Poison Ivy Swamp Thing Feral Trees #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics) 93 Conquest 2099 #1 (Marvel Comics) 95 Godzilla’s Monsterpiece Theatre #1 (IDW Publishing) 123 The Exorcism at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue #1 (IDW Publishing) 136 Toxic Avenger #1 (Of 5) (Ahoy Comics) 137 It Happened On Hyde Street Devour #1 (One-Shot) (Image Comics) 150 Venom War: Fantastic Four #1 (Venom War) (Marvel Comics) 159 Moon is Following Us #1 (Of 10) (Image Comics) 172 Jupiter’s Legacy Finale #1 (Dark Horse Comics) 177 Minky Woodcock Girl Called Cthulhu #1 (Of 4) (Titan Comics) Unranked: Penguin Special #1 (DC Comics) Unranked: Wonder Woman Uncovered #1 (DC Comics) As usual, we will deal with these various issues in their respective franchise sections below. Big Events Venom War 41 Venom #38 (Venom War) 79 Venom War: Wolverine #2 (Venom War) 89 Venom War: Deadpool #2 (Venom War) 91 Venom War #3 (Venom War) (Resolicitation) 94 Venom War: Venomous #3 (Venom War) 121 Venom War: Lethal Protectors #2 (Venom War) 122 Venom War: Carnage #3 (Venom War) 150 Venom War: Fantastic Four #1 (Venom War) 164 Venom War: Zombiotes #3 (Venom War) 184 Venom War: Spider-Man #3 (Venom War) (Resolicitation) Venom War had zero comics in the Top 10, zero comics in the Top 25, and one comic in the Top 50. This was worse than September 2024 when Venom War had zero comics in the Top 10, one comic in the Top 25, and two comics in the Top 50. Venom War: Wolverine #2 fell from the number 55 spot to the number 79 spot. This three-issue limited series is going to struggle to conclude in the Top 100. Venom War: Deadpool #2 ticked down from the number 88 spot to the number 89 spot. This three-issue limited series had a brutal debut, but what was impressive is that there was no drop in sales for the second issue. This title might be able to conclude in the Top 100. Venom War: Venomous #3 climbed from the number 132 spot to the number 94 spot. With this issue, this mini-series concludes. Erica Schultz delivered a sales failure with this mini-series. Venom War: Lethal Protectors #2 climbed from the number 150 spot to the number 121 spot. This three-issue mini-series is a lock to conclude in the Dead Titles Walking category. Hollywood screenwriter Sabir Prizada continues to have no sales success with his comics. Venom War: Carnage #3 ticked up from the number 132 spot to the number 122 spot. This three-issue mini-series is certainly going to finish in the Dead Titles Walking category. Venom War: Fantastic Four #1 had a brutal debut coming in at the number 150 spot. Very few people were interested in checking out Adam Warren’s story in this title. Venom War: Zombiotes #3 ticked up from the number 180 spot to the number 164 spot. This four-issue mini-series from Cavan Scott has been in the Dead Titles Walking category with each issue. That should remain the same for the final issue next month. All of the Venom War tie-in mini-series have been epic sales failures. The biggest reason is the poor selection of writers that Marvel Comics rolled out for these titles. Conquest 2099 93 Conquest 2099 #1 140 Conquest 2099 #2 Conquest 2099 had zero comics in the Top 50. Conquest #1 had a brutal debut coming in at the number 93 spot. Conquest 2099 #2 then fell from the number 93 spot to the number 140 spot. This five-issue mini-series is dead on arrival. Steve Orlando failed to get anyone excited about this story. I had a feeling this would happen. Orlando never has any sales success and his stories can be too cringe-fueled at times.

Venom war je trouve les commentaires un peu trop mauvais. Ca n est certes pas un succés mais ce tait pas non plus calibré pour etre dans le top 10 a mon avis. C est pas un event à l echelle de l editeur.. Mais bon c est aussi clair que ca na pas fonctionné. Pas de sursaut de ventes déjà pour venom.. les ties ins se sont pas vendus.. reste l a vente extra de la mini elle même mais bon ca reste un echec.

Bon hasbro a toujours une franchise qui fonctionne. Image doit se féliciter d avoir acceuilli Kirkman qui leur aura apporté du cash sur la longueur.
Ghost Machine n est pas à son niveau mais bin a celui de reussite aussi..

	Citation:
	Hasbro Franchise 5 Transformers #13 25 Scarlett #5 (Of 5) 33 Destro #5 (Of 5) 37 Void Rivals #13 154 Transformers #12 (Resolicitation) The Hasbro franchise had one comic in the Top 10, two comics in the Top 25, and four comics in the Top 50. This was better than September 2024, when the Hasbro franchise had zero comics in the Top 10, one comic in the Top 25, and three comics in the Top 50. Transformers #13 ticked up from the number 11 spot to the number 5 spot. Thus ends Transformers’ one-month stint outside of the Top 10. We all knew that Transformers was going to get back into the Top 10 after sustaining that initial onslaught of new X-Men titles flooding the market. Scarlett #5 ticked up from the number 26 spot to the number 25 spot. With this final issue, Scarlett managed to sneak back into the Top 25 for a solid final sales ranking for this mini-series. Image Comics seems to be able to do no wrong with their GI Joe mini-series so far. Destro #5 ticked up from the number 37 spot to the number 33 spot. This brings this five-issue mini-series to a conclusion. Once again, Image Comics enjoyed another sales success with a GI Joe title. The GI Joe franchise does not show any signs of cooling off anytime soon. Void Rivals #13 climbed from the number 67 spot to the number 37 spot. This was a great rebound for this title. We normally see Void Rivals in the 30-40 range in the sales rankings. So, normalcy has returned. Spawn Franchise 81 Gunslinger Spawn #36 105 Spawn Scorched #34 112 Spawn Violator #2 (Of 6) 117 Spawn #358 141 Spawn Rat City #7 144 Spawn #357 (Resolicitation) 165 Spawn Sam and Twitch Case Files #7 174 King Spawn #38 (Resolicitation) 185 Spawn Kills Every Spawn #4 (Of 5) The Spawn franchise had zero comics in the Top 50. This was the same as in September 2024, when the Spawn franchise had zero comics in the Top 50. Gunslinger Spawn #36 shot up from the number 108 spot to the number 81 spot. This title returns to where we normally find this title in the sales rankings. Spawn Scorched #34 rocketed from the number 165 spot to the number 105 spot. So close to getting back into the Top 100! Spawn Scorched remains my favorite Spawn title. Spawn Violator #2 fell from the number 85 spot to the number 112 spot. This drop for this six-issue mini-series was expected given the poor debut number. Spawn #358 shot up from the number 188 spot to the number 117 spot. This title is still selling lower than a few issues ago when it was at the number 70 spot. Spawn Rat City #7 climbed from the number 192 spot to the number 141 spot. This title remains doomed to dwell in the Dead Titles Walking category. Spawn Sam and Twitch Case Files #7 climbed from being unranked to the number 165 spot. This title continues to see zero sales success. Spawn Kills Every Spawn #4 climbed from being unranked to the number 185 spot. This five-issue mini-series has been a total sales dud. Ghost Machine Titles 50 Rook Exodus #6 51 Geiger #7 113 Redcoat #7 188 Redcoat #6 (Resolicitation) Ghost Machine had one comic in the Top 50. This was the same as in September 2024, when Ghost Machine had one comic in the Top 50. Rook Exodus #6 dipped from the number 45 spot to the number 50 spot. This title continues to clock in around the number 40-50 spot. Geiger #7 climbed from the number 67 spot to the number 51 spot. This is about where we expect to see this title. Redcoat #7 shot up from the number 142 spot to the number 113 spot. It will be interesting to see if this title can get back to the Top 100 where it had been prior to last month. All in all, Geoff Johns should be quite happy with the sales success of his new imprint. Outside of the Hasbro license, the Ghost Machine titles are the best-selling comics from Image Comics.

J ai pas les chiffres en tete mais j ai l impression qu Image est devenu plus un pole axé sur Kirkhman, Johns mais aussi Vaughan ou Brubaker que sur les fondateurs originels...

	Citation:
	X-Men Franchise 4 Uncanny X-Men #4 6 Wolverine #2 11 X-Men #6 13 Exceptional X-Men #2 26 Mystique #1 29 Ultimate X-Men #8 32 X-Force #4 34 Wolverine Revenge – Red Band #3 39 Sentinels #1 42 X-Men #5 (Resolicitation) 43 X-Factor #3 44 Phoenix #4 65 Dazzler #2 66 Wolverine: Revenge #3 74 Storm #1 (Resolicitation) 75 NYX #4 78 Deadpool #7 (Resolicitation) 79 Venom War: Wolverine #2 (Venom War) 82 Wolverine #1 (Resolicitation) 86 Uncanny X-Men #3 (Resolicitation) 89 Venom War: Deadpool #2 (Venom War) 130 Deadpool Team-Up #3 148 Wolverine: Revenge – Red Band #2 (Resolicitation) 153 X-Men #4 (Resolicitation) 182 Wolverine: Revenge #2 (Resolicitation) 186 Dazzler #1 (Resolicitation) 190 Ultimate X-Men #7 (Resolicitation) 191 Exceptional X-Men #1 (Resolicitation) The X-Men franchise had two comics in the Top 10, four comics in the Top 25, and twelve comics in the Top 50. This was worse than in September 2024, when the X-Men franchise had five comics in the Top 10, ten comics in the Top 25, and thirteen comics in the Top 50. Year-over-year numbers were up as the X-Men franchise had two comics in the Top 10, five comics in the Top 25, and eleven comics in the Top 50 in October 2023. Numbers were up from two years ago as the X-Men franchise had zero comics in the Top 10, four comics in the Top 25, and six comics in the Top 50 in October 2022. Let’s start with the team titles. Uncanny X-Men #4 ticked up from the number 8 spot to the number 4 spot. This is so impressive. Uncanny X-Men continues to be the most valuable brand name in comics. I am convinced that Marvel Comics could hire one of my pugs to write Uncanny X-Men and the power of this brand would continue to generate Top 10 success. X-Men #6 ticked up from the number 17 spot to the number 11 spot. Marvel Comics just missed out on placing two X-Men team titles in the Top 10. Insane. Exceptional X-Men #2 fell from the number 4 spot to the number 13 spot. I fully expect to see this title continue to slide down the sales rankings. X-Force #4 climbed from the number 51 spot to the number 32 spot. This is phenomenal. X-Force #1 debuted at the number 10 spot and then suffered a massive drop as X-Force #2 fell to the number 50 spot. However, X-Force #3 arrested that fall by taking the number 51 spot. And now we have X-Force #4 climbing back up in the rankings. This is very rare to see in a new comic. Normally, once there is a big sales drop the title either slowly descends and finds its happy place in the rankings or the title continues to crash and burn in the sales rankings. But, to see a title suddenly stop its descent after just one issue and then begin climbing back up in the rankings with just the fourth issue. Wow. Very impressive indeed. Congrats to Geoffrey Thorne. Thorne might be on his way to his first sales success in comics. Sentinels #1 had a pedestrian debut taking the number 39 spot. I am not confident that this five-issue limited series will have any sales success. Alex Paknadel is the writer and he has never had any sales success. X-Factor #3 dipped from the number 41 spot to the number 43 spot. This is a positive sign that this title’s fall in the rankings slowed significantly this month. The next few months will be critical in determining the long-term success of this title. NYX #4 dropped from the number 52 spot to the number 75 spot. No surprise here. I expect this Jackson Lanzig and Collin Kelly title to fall out of the Top 100 in the next few months. Let’s hop over to the bad boys of the X-Men franchise. Wolverine #2 ticked down from the number 1 spot to the number 6 spot. Things are looking wonderful for this new title. Wolverine Revenge – Red Band #3 fell from the number 22 spot to the number 34 spot. This five-issue mini-series is doing well and has an excellent chance of concluding in the Top 50. Wolverine: Revenge #3 fell from the number 57 spot to the number 66 spot. The Red Band version of this title is performing at a much higher rate. Deadpool Team-Up #3 dropped from the number 127 spot to the number 130 spot. This five-issue mini-series continues to underperform. Mystique #1 had a solid but not impressive debut taking the number 26 spot. Failing to make the Top 25 with the debut issue indicates that this five-issue mini-series will drop out of the Top 50 in the next month or two. Phoenix #4 climbed from the number 59 spot to the number 44 spot. I am not expecting this title to remain in the Top 50 next month. Dazzler #2 plummeted from the number 15 spot to the number 65 spot. Ouch. It looks like Jason Loo was unable to convince many readers to stick around for the second issue. Having said that, this four-issue mini-series has a chance of concluding in the Top 100.

Pour les titres mutants ca reste pas mal même si on sent certains titres comme NYX glisser vers la fin. Mais vu le nombre ca reste bien.

Pour avengers Cap remonte depuis 2 mois mais reste hors du top 100. Scarlet witch reveint au dessus et comme prévu Immortal Thor revoit le 16 classé certes en dehors du top 100 mais 2 mois de suite donc au dessus comme prévu. A voir son vrai classement avec le top de novembre.

Je vois que FF est dans le top 50 (36) ca reste bien pour ce titre qui n a pas toujours su se maintenir aussi haut.

Action Comics et Superman sont aussi dans le top 50 ce qui est aussi bien pour un personnage qui n a pas toujours pu y etre.

Pour les titres en danger je ne mets que marvel et DC car les autres editeurs n ont pas la regle du top 100

	Citation:
	Dead Titles Walking Based on historical numbers from the Comichron as well as projections through April 2022, titles outside of the Top 100 are usually selling under the 18,000 unit sales mark. These are the Marvel Comics and DC Comics titles that are dead titles walking. Marvel Comics 104 Spider-Society #3 107 Predator Vs. Black Panther #3 118 Spirits of Vengeance #2 121 Venom War: Lethal Protectors #2 (Venom War) 122 Venom War: Carnage #3 (Venom War) 126 Marvel Zombies: Dawn of Decay #2 129 Daredevil: Woman Without Fear #4 130 Deadpool Team-Up #3 140 Conquest 2099 #2 142 Blood Hunters #3 143 Star Wars: The Battle of Jakku #3 150 Venom War: Fantastic Four #1 (Venom War) 164 Venom War: Zombiotes #3 (Venom War) 167 Chasm: Curse of Kaine #3 178 Namor #4 Marvel Comics had fifteen dead titles walking out of their fifty-eight new titles in October 2024. This means that 26% of Marvel Comics’ new titles in October 2024 were dead titles walking. This was down from the thirty-six dead titles walking that Marvel Comics had in September 2024, which comprised 41% of Marvel Comics’ new titles. Year-over-year numbers were up as Marvel Comics had fourteen dead titles walking in October 2023. This comprised 20% of Marvel Comics’ new titles in October 2023. Numbers were up from two years ago, as Marvel Comics had twelve dead titles walking in October 2022. This comprised 14% of Marvel Comics’ new titles in October 2022. Marvel Comics took first place with forty-three new comics in the Top 200 in October 2024. DC Comics 101 Harley Quinn #44 120 Nice House by the Sea #4 (Of 12) 124 Power Girl #14 127 Jenny Sparks #3 (Of 6) 128 John Constantine, Hellblazer Dead in America #10 (Of 11) 157 Multiversus Collision Detection #3 (Of 5) 168 Batman the Brave and the Bold #18 Unranked: Penguin Special #1 Unranked: Wonder Woman Uncovered #1 Unranked: Multiversus Collision Detection #4 (of 5) DC Comics had ten dead titles walking out of DC Comics’ thirty-nine new titles in October 2024. This means that 26% of the new DC Comics titles in October 2024 were dead titles walking. This was down from the thirty-nine dead titles walking that DC Comics had in September 2024 which comprised 63% of DC Comics’ new titles. Year-over-year numbers were down as DC Comics had twenty-six dead titles walking in October 2023. This comprised 46% of DC Comics’ new titles in October 2023. Numbers were down from two years ago as DC Comics had twenty-nine dead titles walking in October 2022. This comprised 43% of DC Comics’ new titles in October 2022. DC Comics took third place with thirty-six new comics in the Top 200 in October 2024.

Namor est un echec cuisant. Il est moins etonnant d y voir Blood Hunters qui part sans persos vendeurs et sans equipe creative un tant soit peu vendeuse

Chez DC la mode Harley Quinn est bien passée.. Constantine ne vend pas plus intégré à l univers DC qu avant.. mais je pense que les TP ne sont pas au même niveau. Peut etre que Vertigo étant de retour.
Jenny SParks ne fonctionne pas mais il me semble qu human target ou dangers street n etaient pas haut. Je suppose que King vend sur le marché du TP lui aussi en librairie classique (où on a pas de chiffres)

https://icv2.com/articles/markets/vi...s-october-2024
https://www.comicbookrevolution.com/...ales-rankings/

[scarletneedle]

https://bleedingcool.com/comics/25-t...book-industry/

Le truc qui fait flipper et qui pourrait me faire arrêter beaucoup de titres voire la vo...

[Fred le mallrat]

Et n oublie pas que le dernier mandat de Trump avait ramené les droits de douane

[mrcitrouille]

Disons que l inflation en général et des comics à 4% minimum m ont bien fait revoir mes achats à la baisse.

Bon aucun risque que je me mette à la VF mais je suppose que je vais continuer à acheter en occaz (et puis bon y a pas grands trucs chez les Big two pour lesquels je ne peux pas attendre un peu donc bon)

[Fred le mallrat]

Le truc qui va se combiner c est qu ol semble (en yout cas à bordeaux) que les commerces vont mal..
Et quand on va perdre encore plus en "pouvoir d achat" c est les loisirs qui trinquent

[ollieno]

	Citation:			Posté par Fred le mallrat
	Et n oublie pas que le dernier mandat de Trump avait ramené les droits de douane

Oui, mais ..cette fois, Trudeau (le Premier Ministre Canadien) à rappeler que le Canada est l'un des importateur essentiel, pour les USA.. Vu qu'ils fournissent 60% du Pétrole et 85 % de l'électricité ...

[Fred le mallrat]

Top 50 Novembre 2024
https://icv2.com/articles/markets/vi...-november-2024

Absolute mange tout même les reassorts sont dans le top 20
Ultimate se maintient et rafle pas mal.
GIJoe est un succés!
Spidey tient bon avec eux.
Justice League Unlimited ce st compliqué à dire... 7ème c est pas terrible en soit mais on a pas les chiffres de ventes.. alors je sais pas ce qui a dans le spiderman 61 qui est devant mais sinon c est des #1 ou l'ouragan absolute...
Mais si on est à moins de 100 000.. ca sera pas top.

Les titres mutants restent dans le top 20 pour la plupart. Avengers aussi.
WCA, JSA, Batgirl,Psylocke ou Question ont des lancements qui sont pas deconnants par rapport aux equipes creatives et aux séries.. a voir surtout si elles se stabilisent vite ou pas.
Le relaunch de MK par Mackay reste dans le top 50 pour son #2.. Mackay aura gardé ce titre assez longtemps si on prend tous les numéros sur de bonnes ventes. une premiere pour le perso sur une telle longueur. Certes la periode finch avait bien vendue mais aprés le départ c etait descendu vite.. et il etait partie bien avant le total de numéros de mackay

Si on regarde de plus prés le top dans son ensemble (top 200)

	Citation:
	1 Absolute Superman #1 (DC Comics) 3 GI Joe #1 (Image Comics) 7 Justice League Unlimited #1 (DC Comics) 12 Psylocke #1 (Marvel Comics) 15 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles/Naruto #1 (IDW Publishing) 16 Absolute Wonder Woman #1 (DC Comics) 17 Absolute Batman #1 (DC Comics) 19 Batgirl #1 (DC Comics) 23 Absolute Batman Noir Edition #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics) 24 JSA #1 (DC Comics) 27 West Coast Avengers #1 (Marvel Comics) 44 Venom War: It’s Jeff #1 (Venom War) (Marvel Comics) 49 Question All Along The Watchtower #1 (Of 6) (DC Comics) 68 Black Canary Best of the Best #1 (Of 6) (DC Comics) 72 Marvel & Disney What If…? Minnie Became Captain Marvel #1 (Marvel Comics) 74 Kahhori Reshaper of Worlds A Marvel Voices Special #1 (Marvel Comics) 83 Batman Santa Claus Silent Knight Returns #1 (Of 5) (DC Comics) 86 DuckTales #1 (Dynamite Ent.) 91 Rocketfellers #1 (Image Comics) 95 Black Lightning #1 (DC Comics) 99 FML #1 (Dark Horse Comics) 107 Power Rangers Prime #1 (BOOM! Studios) 114 Heat Seeker Combustion Gun Honey Series #1 (Titan Comics) 116 Green Arrow 2024 Annual #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics) 128 DC All-In Special #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics) 139 Arcbound #1 (Dark Horse Comics) 152 One for Sorrow #1 (Of 3) (DSTLRY) 156 Poison Ivy Swamp Thing Feral Trees #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics) 157 Negasonic Teenage Warhead #1 (Marvel Comics) 168 Batman Uncovered #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics) 182 Absolute Wonder Woman Noir Edition #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics) 184 Little Batman Month One #1 (Of 4) (DC Comics) Unranked: Milestone Universe: The Shadow Cabinet #1 (DC Comics)

Je trouve qu on aurait attendu plus de Black Canary

	Citation:
	25 Venom War #4 30 Venom #39 44 Venom War: It’s Jeff #1 50 Venom War #5 85 Venom War: Spider-Man #4 103 Venom War: Deadpool #3 104 Venom War: Wolverine #3 160 Venom War: Lethal Protectors #3

Venom war, Jeff et venom se vendent bien mais là on voit bien la limite des innombrables ties ins... Il est temps de faire plus resserré quand on est sur un event sur une famille de titres ou qui ne le nécessite pas.

	Citation:
	3 GI Joe #1 14 Transformers #14 87 Void Rivals #14 105 GI Joe A Real American Hero #311 187 Void Rivals #13 (Resolicitation) 192 Transformers #13 (Resolicitation)

Energonverse se porte trés bien

	Citation:
	71 Geiger #8 133 Hyde Street #2

Ghost Machine marque le pas mais ca reste trés bien pour de l'indé et surtout un univers partagé autre que le big two.

	Citation:
	Spider-Man Franchise 4 Ultimate Spider-Man #11 5 Amazing Spider-Man #61 25 Venom War #4 (Venom War) 26 Amazing Spider-Man #62 30 Venom #39 (Venom War) 40 Amazing Spider-Man #60 (Resolicitation) 44 Venom War: It’s Jeff #1 (Venom War) 50 Venom War #5 (Venom War) 55 Spider-Man: Black Suit & Blood #4 58 Spectacular Spider-Men #9 73 Spider-Gwen: The Ghost-Spider #7 78 Miles Morales: Spider-Man #26 85 Venom War: Spider-Man #4 (Venom War) 88 Ultimate Spider-Man #10 (Resolicitation) 92 Spider-Boy #13 93 Spider-Man Reign 2 #5 102 Spider-Society #4 103 Venom War: Deadpool #3 (Venom War) 104 Venom War: Wolverine #3 (Venom War) 130 Kid Venom #3 160 Venom War: Lethal Protectors #3 (Venom War) 176 Chasm: Curse of Kaine #4 198 Spider-Boy #12 (Resolicitation) 199 Amazing Spider-Man #59 (Resolicitation) Unranked: Spider-Man: Homeroom Heroes

Il doit y avoir un peu trop de titres assimilés à Spiderman ou venom.

	Citation:
	X-Men Franchise 8 Uncanny X-Men #5 11 X-Men #7 12 Psylocke #1 18 Wolverine #3 20 Ultimate X-Men #9 22 Uncanny X-Men #6 29 Exceptional X-Men #3 34 X-Force #5 36 Storm #2 38 Deadpool #8 42 NYX #5 43 X-Factor #4 48 Phoenix #5 66 Ultimate X-Men #8 (Resolicitation) 89 Wolverine Revenge – Red Band #3 (Resolicitation) 103 Venom War: Deadpool #3 (Venom War) 104 Venom War: Wolverine #3 (Venom War) 109 Sentinels #2 121 Mystique #2 136 Wolverine: Revenge #3 (Resolicitation) 138 X-Men #6 (Resolicitation) 140 Dazzler #3 142 Uncanny X-Men #4 (Resolicitation) 148 Wolverine #2 (Resolicitation) 153 NYX #4 (Resolicitation) 157 Negasonic Teenage Warhead #1

Toutes les ongoings sont dans le top 50.. ce st quand même pas mal.
Je pense que Marvel attendait mieux de Mystique.

	Citation:
	9 Ultimates #6 10 Aliens Vs. Avengers #2 27 West Coast Avengers #1 32 Avengers #20 53 Immortal Thor #17 61 Scarlet Witch #6 63 Ultimate Black Panther #10 65 Iron Man #2 70 Predator vs. Black Panther #4 72 Marvel & Disney What If…? Minnie Became Captain Marvel #1 77 Incredible Hulk #19 84 Captain America #15 100 Avengers Assemble #3 125 Iron Man #1 (Resolicitation) 164 Predator Vs. Black Panther #3 (Resolicitation) 189 Captain America #14 (Resolicitation)

Avengers Vs Alien marche bien et je trouve ca mérité car c est une série interessante.
Avengers, thor ou Scarlet Witch progressent.
Hulk decroche.. Iron Man commence a ressembler à un accident industriel vu la chute (et a ce stade personne n a lu le 1 quand les ventes du 2 sont faites).. il vaudrait mieux que la lecture convainque les lecteurs car en tout cas l initiative n a pas convaincu en amont.
Captain America remonte un peu mais si peu..

	Citation:
	4 Ultimate Spider-Man #11 9 Ultimates #6 20 Ultimate X-Men #9 63 Ultimate Black Panther #10 66 Ultimate X-Men #8 (Resolicitation) 88 Ultimate Spider-Man #10 (Resolicitation)

Surpris par le decrochage de BP.. là où j en suis c est pas mal du tout.. mais bon globalement la ligne ultimate est un succés

	Citation:
	2 Absolute Batman #2 13 Batman #154 17 Absolute Batman #1 (Resolicitation) 19 Batgirl #1 23 Absolute Batman Noir Edition #1 (One-Shot) 31 Batman and Robin Year One #2 (Of 12) 37 Batman the Long Halloween: The Last Halloween #3 (Of 10) 39 Batman Full Moon #2 (Of 4) 52 Detective Comics #1091 54 Batman Superman World’s Finest #33 64 Batman Gotham by Gaslight: The Kryptonian Age #6 (Of 6) 67 Batman and Robin #15 76 Batman the Long Halloween: The Last Halloween #2 (Of 10) (Resolicitation) 81 Nightwing #120 83 Batman Santa Claus Silent Knight Returns #1 (Of 5) 98 Birds of Prey #15 110 Batman Dark Age #6 (Of 6) 113 Dark Knights of Steel Allwinter #5 (Of 6) 124 Catwoman #70 150 Detective Comics #1090 (Resolicitation) 155 Batman Full Moon #1 (Of 4) (Resolicitation) 156 Poison Ivy Swamp Thing Feral Trees #1 (One-Shot) (Resolicitation) 163 Nightwing #119 (Resolicitation) 168 Batman Uncovered #1 (One-Shot) 184 Little Batman Month One #1 (Of 4) 193 Batman #153 (Resolicitation) Unranked: Batman: The Brave and the Bold #19 Unranked: The Batman & Scooby-Doo Mysteries #11

Cela fait quelques mois que Batman n arrive plus a etre dans le top 10... Bon aprés entre la ligne absolute et la ligne ultimate... seul spidey a glissé un numéro dans le tas.
detective est déjà revenu hors du top 50. La venue de Taylor a fait pourtant parlé mais n a pas convaincu les comics shops au-delà de leurs commandes de clients mais là aussi on est avant lecture.
La suite de long halloween ne sera pas le même succés que ces séries précédentes.
Nightwing dévisse avec son changement de scenariste.
Catwoman reste dans les titres qui ont une épée de damocles au-dessus de leur tête

	Citation:
	Superman Franchise 1 Absolute Superman #1 45 Action Comics #1075 47 Action Comics #1074 54 Batman Superman World’s Finest #33 56 Superman #20 59 Action Comics #1076 115 Action Comics #1077 179 Power Girl #15 188 Superman #19 (Resolicitation) Unranked: My Adventures with Superman #6

Superman sort du top 50 après des baisses. Cela fait 3 numeros que Superman sort du top 30 et là c est du top 50...

	Citation:
	Justice League Franchise 6 Absolute Wonder Woman #2 7 Justice League Unlimited #1 16 Absolute Wonder Woman #1 (Resolicitation) 24 JSA #1 41 Wonder Woman #15 68 Black Canary Best of the Best #1 (Of 6) 69 Green Lantern #17 95 Black Lightning #1 101 Plastic Man No More #3 (Of 4) 116 Green Arrow 2024 Annual #1 (One-Shot) 145 Green Arrow #18 172 The Flash #15

All-In a eu peu d effet sur les ventes des titres hors le numéro inaugural..

	Citation:
	Dead Titles Walking Based on historical numbers from the Comichron as well as projections through April 2022, titles outside of the Top 100 are usually selling under the 18,000 unit sales mark. These are the Marvel Comics and DC Comics titles that are dead titles walking. Marvel Comics 102 Spider-Society #4 103 Venom War: Deadpool #3 (Venom War) 104 Venom War: Wolverine #3 (Venom War) 109 Sentinels #2 120 Star Wars: The Battle of Jakku #5 Republic Under Siege 121 Mystique #2 127 Blade: Red Band #2 130 Kid Venom #3 131 Star Wars: Ahsoka #5 137 Star Wars: Ewoks #2 140 Dazzler #3 149 Conquest 2099 #3 157 Negasonic Teenage Warhead #1 160 Venom War: Lethal Protectors #3 (Venom War) 162 Blood Hunters #4 164 Predator Vs. Black Panther #3 176 Chasm: Curse of Kaine #4 177 Marvel Zombies: Dawn of Decay #3 183 Star Wars: The Battle of Jakku #6 Republic Under Siege 185 Spirits of Vengeance #3 Unranked: Spider-Man: Homeroom Heroes DC Comics 101 Plastic Man No More #3 (Of 4) 110 Batman Dark Age #6 (Of 6) 113 Dark Knights of Steel Allwinter #5 (Of 6) 115 Action Comics #1077 116 Green Arrow 2024 Annual #1 (One-Shot) 124 Catwoman #70 145 Green Arrow #18 151 Jenny Sparks #4 (Of 7) 158 DC Horror Presents Creature Commandos #2 (Of 6) 165 Shazam #17 168 Batman Uncovered #1 (One-Shot) 172 The Flash #15 179 Power Girl #15 182 Absolute Wonder Woman Noir Edition #1 (One-Shot) 184 Little Batman Month One #1 (Of 4) 194 Nice House by the Sea #4 (Of 12) 195 Multiversus Collision Detection #5 (Of 6) Unranked: My Adventures with Superman #6 Unranked: Batman: The Brave and the Bold #19 Unranked: Milestone Universe: The Shadow Cabinet #1 Unranked: Multiversus Collision Detection #6 (of 6) Unranked: The Batman & Scooby-Doo Mysteries #11 Unranked: Looney Tunes #281

Sans surprise Blood Hunters ne durera pas.. Peut être plus surprenant Spirits of vengeance non plus
étonné que Power Girl, Flash soit encore là.. Green arrow est en danger avec Catwoman.
Quand on voit les ventes de Jenny Sparks ou Black Canary.. on se dit que Tom King doit vendre beaucoup en TP.. surtout que Danger street c etait aussi bas que Jenny..

https://www.comicbookrevolution.com/...tman-franchise

[Fred le mallrat]

Top 50 de décembre
https://icv2.com/articles/markets/vi...-december-2024

Absolute et Ultimate mangent tout... Les reassorts Absolute continuent d etre dans le top 20
JLU aussi a un reassort dans le top 30.. compliqué de juger les titres DC si on a des reassorts comme ca..

les nouveaux titres Laura Kinney ou Hellverine s en sortent bien All-New Venom c est quand même un succés.
J ai envie de dire pareil pour New Gods

Timeslide c est passé de mode.. assez décevant .. TVA.. je sais pas quoi en dire.. on va dire que c est pas malsi on prend le public comics...

FF est à une bonne place. Meilleure que depuis des decennies il me semble.

Un point sur le Top 200 et plus
https://www.comicbookrevolution.com/...ales-rankings/

	Citation:
	3 Ultimate Universe One Year In #1 (Marvel Comics) 6 All-New Venom #1 (Marvel Comics) 16 Laura Kinney: Wolverine #1 (Marvel Comics) 20 Deadpool/Wolverine #1 (Marvel Comics) 27 New Gods #1 (Of 12) (DC Comics) 31 Hellverine #1 (Marvel Comics) 32 Batman Dark Patterns #1 (Of 12) (DC Comics) 43 Timeslide #1 (Marvel Comics) 45 TVA #1 (Marvel Comics) 54 Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #1 (Marvel Comics) 56 Hellhunters #1 (Marvel Comics) 67 Deadly Tales of the Gunslinger Spawn #1 (Image Comics) 70 Challengers of the Unknown #1 (Of 6) (DC Comics) 73 What If…? Galactus – Galactus Transformed Hulk? #1 (Marvel Comics) 74 Sam Wilson: Captain America #1 (Marvel Comics) 78 Superwoman Special #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics) 79 Two-Face #1 (Of 6) (DC Comics) 81 Deadpool/Wolverine: Weapon X-Traction #1 (Marvel Comics) 82 West Coast Avengers #1 (Marvel Comics) (Resolicitation) 84 Alien: Paradiso #1 (Marvel Comics) 90 ThunderCats Apex #1 (Dynamite Ent.) 94 Cable Love and Chrome #1 (Marvel Comics) 96 Green Lantern Green Arrow World’s Finest Special #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics) 104 Sabretooth: The Dead Don’t Talk #1 (Marvel Comics) 105 Kidpool/Spider-Boy #1 (Marvel Comics) 112 Infinity Watch #1 (Marvel Comics) 119 EC Shiver Suspenstories #1 (Oni Press) 122 Marvel Holiday Tales to Astonish #1 (Marvel Comics) 129 DC’s Batman Smells Robin Laid an Egg #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics) 130 Petpool Pool Party #1 (Marvel Comics) 139 Metamorpho The Element Man #1 (DC Comics) 153 Creepshow 2024 Holiday Special (One-Shot) (Image Comics) 168 Justice League The Atom Project #1 (Of 6) (DC Comics) 192 Gotham City Sirens Uncovered #1 (One-Shot) (DC Comics)

Si Sam Wilson n etait pas sur la 5eme semaine... c est la cata industrielle du mois.
Je dis pas qu on attendait un top 10.. mais disons qu un top 20 ou 25 était le minimum. On va me dire qu infinity watch 1 est après.. oui mais c est un échec..mais pas de la meme envergure. Comme on attend pas de metamorpho d être dans le top 20. Là aussi c est la cata (si c est bien les chiffres) mais pas industrielle.. car on attend pas de metamorpho des chiffres à la captain america (dont on attend pas des chiffres à la xmen mais quand même).
Alanna Smith a du pain sur la planche depuis que Breevort lui a donné les clé de Captain America, ce sont des echecs commerciaux qui s empilent.

	Citation:
	X-Men Franchise 7 X-Men #8 (Raid on Graymalkin) 8 Uncanny X-Men #7 (Raid on Graymalkin) 13 Wolverine #4 16 Laura Kinney: Wolverine #1 19 X-Men #9 (Raid on Graymalkin) 20 Deadpool/Wolverine #1 28 Ultimate X-Men #10 34 Uncanny X-Men #6 (Resolicitation) 35 Psylocke #2 39 Storm #3 41 X-Force #6 43 Timeslide #1 46 NYX #6 57 X-Factor #5 64 Exceptional X-Men #4 68 Deadpool #9 72 Phoenix #6 81 Deadpool/Wolverine: Weapon X-Traction #1 87 X-Force #7 93 Dazzler #4 94 Cable Love and Chrome #1 102 X-Factor #6 104 Sabretooth: The Dead Don’t Talk #1 105 Kidpool/Spider-Boy #1 130 Petpool Pool Party #1 135 Mystique #3 144 Sentinels #3 148 Deadpool Team-Up #4 184 Wolverine #3 (Resolicitation)

Si les chiffres de Xceptionnal sont les bons, c est aussi un souci... NYX serait devant ce titre xmen?
Pour le reste les chiffres tiennent bons avec quelques décrochages mais soit des minis soit des titres dont on se doutait qu'ils n allaient pas suivre éternellement (Phoenix, Dazzler..). On peut s interroger quand même sur Xforce

	Citation:
	Spider-Man Franchise 4 Ultimate Spider-Man #12 6 All-New Venom #1 9 Amazing Spider-Man #63 22 Amazing Spider-Man #64 33 Amazing Spider-Man #62 (Resolicitation) 54 Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #1 59 Miles Morales: Spider-Man #27 69 Ultimate Spider-Man #11 (Resolicitation) 83 Spider-Gwen: The Ghost-Spider #8 98 Spectacular Spider-Men #10 105 Kidpool/Spider-Boy #1 106 Venom War #5 (Resolicitation) 132 Miles Morales Spider-Man #28 136 Amazing Spider-Man #61 (Resolicitation) 150 Spider-Gwen: The Ghost-Spider #9 152 Spider-Boy #14 156 Spectacular Spider-Men #1 189 Spider-Boy #13 (Resolicitation) Unranked: Spidery & His Amazing Friends #2

Rien à dire

	Citation:
	Avengers Franchise 10 Ultimates #7 25 Ultimates #8 29 Avengers #21 48 Incredible Hulk #20 60 Ultimate Black Panther #11 62 Scarlet Witch #7 63 Iron Man #3 71 Avengers #22 73 What If…? Galactus – Galactus Transformed Hulk? #1 74 Sam Wilson: Captain America #1 77 Immortal Thor #18 82 West Coast Avengers #1 (Resolicitation) 91 Captain America #16 95 West Coast Avengers #2 128 Avengers Assemble #4 138 Incredible Hulk #19 (Resolicitation) 154 Iron Man #2 (Resolicitation) 159 Ultimate Black Panther #10 (Resolicitation) Unranked: Ultraman X Avengers #3

Scarlet Witch tient bien.
Je me suis trompé et ca se révèle ne pas avoir joué sur les ventesces deux relaunchs. Marvel a du y gagner.
Immortal Thor dévisse mais la partie graphique n est pas à la hauteur du titre. A voir quand même car sur certains mois le devissageétait lié à la semaine de vente.

Cap? Nuff said

	Citation:
	3 Ultimate Universe One Year In #1 4 Ultimate Spider-Man #12 10 Ultimates #7 25 Ultimates #8 28 Ultimate X-Men #10 60 Ultimate Black Panther #11 69 Ultimate Spider-Man #11 (Resolicitation) 159 Ultimate Black Panther #10 (Resolicitation)

	Citation:
	Batman Franchise 1 Absolute Batman #3 11 Absolute Batman #1 (Resolicitation) 12 Batman #155 18 Absolute Batman #2 (Resolicitation) 32 Batman Dark Patterns #1 (Of 12) 36 Batman the Long Halloween: The Last Halloween #4 (Of 10) 38 Batman and Robin Year One #3 (Of 12) 40 Batman Gargoyle of Gotham #3 (Of 4) 42 Batman #156 49 Nightwing #121 52 Batman Superman World’s Finest #34 53 Batgirl #2 58 Detective Comics #1092 75 Poison Ivy #28 79 Two-Face #1 (Of 6) 92 Batman the Long Halloween: The Last Halloween #3 (Of 10) (Resolicitation) 109 Batman and Robin #16 113 Detective Comics #1091 (Resolicitation) 114 Batman Santa Claus Silent Knight Returns #2 (Of 5) 118 Catwoman #71 123 Birds of Prey #16 129 DC’s Batman Smells Robin Laid an Egg #1 (One-Shot) 134 Batman Santa Claus Silent Knight Returns #3 (Of 5) 137 Batman Full Moon #3 (Of 4) 142 Dark Knights of Steel Allwinter #6 (Of 6) 147 Batman Santa Claus Silent Knight Returns #4 (Of 5) 151 Batman ’89 Echoes #5 (Of 6) 161 Nightwing #120 (Resolicitation) 162 Batgirl #3 175 Batman Santa Claus Silent Knight Returns #5 (Of 5) 183 Harley Quinn #46 192 Gotham City Sirens Uncovered #1 (One-Shot) 194 Poison Ivy #29 199 Batman Santa Claus Silent Knight Returns #1 (Of 5) (Resolicitation) Unranked: Birds of Prey #17 Unranked: Two-Face #2 Unranked: Batman: The Brave and the Bold #20 Unranked: Little Batman: Month One #2 Unranked: Batman: Gargoyle of Gotham – Noir Edition #3 Unranked: The Batman & Scooby-Doo Mysteries #12

Detective est revenu aux ventes avant All in. Bon là ca vend pour les meilleurs titres mai sil y a bien trop de titres.

	Citation:
	Superman Franchise 2 Absolute Superman #2 15 Absolute Superman #3 24 Absolute Superman #1 (Resolicitation) 44 Action Comics #1078 52 Batman Superman World’s Finest #34 55 Superman #21 78 Superwoman Special #1 (One-Shot) 85 Action Comics #1080 86 Action Comics #1079 88 Absolute Superman Noir Edition #1 (One-Shot) 101 Action Comics #1081 141 Superman #20 (Resolicitation) Unranked: Power Girl #16

C est pas mal pour du Superman. Ca a un peu baissé depuis quelques mois mais ca reste pas mal.

	Citation:
	Justice League Franchise 5 Absolute Wonder Woman #3 17 Absolute Wonder Woman #2 (Resolicitation) 21 Justice League Unlimited #2 26 Justice League Unlimited #1 (Resolicitation) 47 Wonder Woman #16 50 JSA #2 51 Absolute Wonder Woman #1 (Resolicitation) 65 Green Lantern #18 96 Green Lantern Green Arrow World’s Finest Special #1 (One-Shot) 121 Black Canary Best of the Best #2 (Of 6) 139 Metamorpho The Element Man #1 157 Plastic Man No More #4 (Of 4) 165 JSA #3 168 Justice League The Atom Project #1 (Of 6) 174 Black Canary Best of the Best #1 (Of 6) (Resolicitation) 176 Green Lantern Dark #2 (Of 7) 185 The Flash #16 187 Green Arrow #19 Unranked: Black Lightning #2

JLU et WW c est trés bien. GL aussi.
JSA c estinquietant. GA on va lui dire au revoir..

	Citation:
	The Absolute Universe 1 Absolute Batman #3 2 Absolute Superman #2 5 Absolute Wonder Woman #3 11 Absolute Batman #1 (Resolicitation) 15 Absolute Superman #3 17 Absolute Wonder Woman #2 (Resolicitation) 18 Absolute Batman #2 (Resolicitation) 24 Absolute Superman #1 (Resolicitation) 51 Absolute Wonder Woman #1 (Resolicitation) 88 Absolute Superman Noir Edition #1 (One-Shot)

Ca c est de la vente... c est pour l instant un coup de maitre

	Citation:
	Dead Titles Walking Based on historical numbers from the Comichron as well as projections through April 2022, titles outside of the Top 100 are usually selling under the 18,000 unit sales mark. These are the Marvel Comics and DC Comics titles that are dead titles walking. Marvel Comics 100 Daredevil #17 102 X-Factor #6 104 Sabretooth: The Dead Don’t Talk #1 105 Kidpool/Spider-Boy #1 108 Werewolf by Night Red Band #5 111 Star Wars: The Battle of Jakku #7 Republic Under Siege 112 Infinity Watch #1 122 Marvel Holiday Tales to Astonish #1 128 Avengers Assemble #4 130 Petpool Pool Party #1 131 Blade: Red Band #3 132 Miles Morales Spider-Man #28 135 Mystique #3 143 Star Wars: The Battle of Jakku #8 Republic Under Siege 144 Sentinels #3 148 Deadpool Team-Up #4 150 Spider-Gwen: The Ghost-Spider #9 152 Spider-Boy #14 156 Spectacular Spider-Men #11 169 Marvel Super Heroes Secret Wars #12 Facsimile Edition 171 Star Wars: Ahsoka #6 177 Star Wars: The Battle of Jakku #9 Last Stand 179 Conquest 2099 #4 182 Werewolf by Night Red Band #6 186 Spirits of Vengeance #4 190 Marvel Zombies: Dawn of Decay #4 200 Star Wars: Ewoks #3 Unranked: Namor #5 Unranked: Blood Hunters #5 Unranked: Star Wars: Ahsoka #7 Unranked: Spidery & His Amazing Friends #2 Unranked: Conquest 2099 #5 Unranked: Ultraman X Avengers #3 DC Comics 101 Action Comics #1081 103 Titans #18 109 Batman and Robin #16 114 Batman Santa Claus Silent Knight Returns #2 (Of 5) 116 Question All Along the Watchtower #2 (Of 6) 118 Catwoman #71 120 DC Horror Presents #2 (Of 3) 121 Black Canary Best of the Best #2 (Of 6) 123 Birds of Prey #16 125 DC Vs Vampires World War V #5 (Of 12) 129 DC’s Batman Smells Robin Laid an Egg #1 (One-Shot) 134 Batman Santa Claus Silent Knight Returns #3 (Of 5) 137 Batman Full Moon #3 (Of 4) 139 Metamorpho The Element Man #1 141 Superman #20 (Resolicitation) 142 Dark Knights of Steel Allwinter #6 (Of 6) 147 Batman Santa Claus Silent Knight Returns #4 (Of 5) 151 Batman ’89 Echoes #5 (Of 6) 157 Plastic Man No More #4 (Of 4) 161 Nightwing #120 (Resolicitation) 162 Batgirl #3 165 JSA #3 167 John Constantine, Hellblazer Dead in America #11 (Of 11) 168 Justice League The Atom Project #1 (Of 6) 175 Batman Santa Claus Silent Knight Returns #5 (Of 5) 176 Green Lantern Dark #2 (Of 7) 183 Harley Quinn #46 185 The Flash #16 187 Green Arrow #19 192 Gotham City Sirens Uncovered #1 (One-Shot) 193 Jenny Sparks #5 (Of 7) 194 Poison Ivy #29 198 DC Horror Presents #3 (Of 3) Unranked: Black Lightning #2 Unranked: Birds of Prey #17 Unranked: Power Girl #16 Unranked: Shazam! #18 Unranked: Shazam! #19 Unranked: Two-Face #2 Unranked: DC Horror Presents: Creature Commandos #3 Unranked: DC Horror Presents: Creature Commandos #4 Unranked: Milestone Universe: The Shadow Cabinet #2 Unranked: Batman: The Brave and the Bold #20 Unranked: Little Batman: Month One #2 Unranked: Batman: Gargoyle of Gotham – Noir Edition #3 Unranked: The Batman & Scooby-Doo Mysteries #12 Unranked: Scooby-Doo, Where Are You? #131

Daredevil c est inquiétant.
Flash je sais toujours pas comment on a pas eu un relaunch.. Batgirl c est pas top du tout
On voit que DC a baissé sa ligne de flottaison. Il y a bien trop de titres qui sont là depuis des mois...
Par contre Shazam et BoP... c est finito

[Fred le mallrat]

Top 50 2024 avec un top 5 de 4 absolute et Ultimate spidey...
La suite montre que ces deux univers ont marqué cette année
L energon Universe s en sort bien et quelques séries indés ont eu un bon départ comme TMNT ou Thundercats.
https://icv2.com/articles/markets/vi...full-year-2024

Le Top 50 de Janvier
https://icv2.com/articles/markets/vi...s-january-2025
Ultimates et absolute toujours en tête.
magik # 1 cree la surprise sur ce top 5 et est suivi de Rogue.. Tous les titres solos xmen ne sont pas classés aussi haut.

Aquaman est une bonne surprise. Deadpool/Wolvie est toujours là donc les ventes de décembre étaient pas complète.. il etait donc dans le top 10au moins.

Daredevil Unleash Hell - Red Band #1 est aussi une bonne nouvelle en 20 pour un comics Red Band et sous plastic bag

New Gods se maintient trés bien.
New Champions pour moi c est une surprise.. car bon j ai pas été marqué plus que ca par ses persos issus de spiderwoman.

Laura Kinney se maintient et on peut dire qu Exceptional Xmen avait eu surement une partie de ses ventes non comptabilisées (5eme semaine) car là il revient dans le top 50 comme Immortal Thor (autre erreur). Deux titres qui se portent donc bien.

Je vois le numero 4 d Iron Man que j attendais pas là aprés avoir lu un #1 qui m a pas convaincu.

[mugiwaraya]

	Citation:			Posté par Fred le mallrat
	New Champions pour moi c est une surprise.. car bon j ai pas été marqué plus que ca par ses persos issus de spiderwoman.

Pour un numéro 1, c'est quand même pas extraordinaire. Je m'attends à ce que le 2 sorte du top 50.

Magik en 5è place, c'est déjà mieux, mais bon, je ne vais pas me réjouir trop vite. Couverture de Campbell, effet Marvel Rivals...

NYX garde une place assez convenable je trouve, ce qui rendra encore plus incompréhensible l'arrêt s'il est confirmé.

Spider-Boy se casse la gueule et c'est dommage. Je ne sais pas ce que le comics vaut, mais je vois beaucoup de monde le haïr pour les mauvaises raisons. Son succès m'aurait offert un peu de Schadenfreude.

[Fred le mallrat]

Oui mais new champions y a pas un perso connu.. pas un auteur vraiment vendeur et ça fait mieux sue sam Wilson ou tva ou challengers of the unknown

Je dis pas que c est bien mais c est pas un échec non plus...
Vu les ventes des titres que j ai cité (et je cite pas letamorpho qui doit avoir un souci de chiffres).. je le dis que c est pas si mal vu que rien n est connu
Les persos sont apparus dans spiderwoman qui était déjà hors du top 100 à ce moment là
Et moi qui ait lu spiderwoman.. j ai pas une envie irresisti le de lire un titre avec ces personnages là..

Avec tout ça oui je trouve que c est pas si mal que ce soit classé ka car c est un titre dont l échec est déjà assuré

[Fred le mallrat]

Je viens de voir qu alanna smith est l éditrice de New champions...
A part scarlet witch elle a pas beaucoup de réussite depuis qu elle est senior editor.. je dis ça sans méchanceté car j aime les séries cap et tbolts qu elle a faites avec Kelly et Lazing..